Jake65, are you referring to ingredients or diplomas, because I have the same number of ingredients as Silly Bubbles, which is 12. My point is, I can only slot 13 ingredients into my recipe while remaining within my witch points limit, by choosing the lowest costing ingredient each time. In Silly Bubble's graphic above, there are 22 ingredients in the pot. No use of diamonds by the looks of it. Is that number chapter related ? I am in halflings. Or am I reading the information incorrectly. The number of ingredients also seems to increase the success rate.