Silly Bubbles
Necromancer
To get this bit out of the way first, because I don´t see the point what that has to do with the discussion at all:
The point is that whatever conclusion forums come to doesn't necessarily represent the view of majority of players. To be honest I don't think it represents any major group, people usually choose to get involved in forums for different reasons than their playing style. That's why there's no need to aim to win the argument and it's completely fine to agree to disagree. There's no need to push opinions on others or try hard to prove others wrong. It's all about sharing different opinions, views and strategies so others can pick and choose what they like out of it. The more opinions the better, we all have different playing styles so the more players post the more likely we'll find what is useful to us.