I really don’t want to upset people who don’t want to discuss things about formulae / tuning / designing your city at your will.
As long as it’s correct and considers all aspects of the game, there’s no reason why you should not post your findings. MinMax was great with numbers but not as much so in practical applications or strategies. I also have never seen her/his main city to see the results of the strategies as it was under a different user name.
The main problem is that the strategy that was created based on this formula didn’t consider the benefits of AW upgrades, expansions, research etc. All it needs is just to look at people’s tournament results to see that progressing (AW upgrades, expansions, research) doesn’t reduce their tournament score, it actually increases it. Any strategy that is not supported by actual results is wrong and can be damaging to the game if it gets accepted by large number of players. Unfortunately, this one widely spread amongst players and seems to be very hard to correct it as you can see.